The Success Wound with Brooke Taylor

Photo of the back of a woman in black jacket, sitting atop a mountain summit

Prefer to follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify (or your other favorite platform)?

Click here to find our show. Give us a follow to be sure you don’t miss new episodes!

The Success Wound: Achievement, Identity, and Redefining What Fulfillment Means

In this episode of the Two Piers Podcast, Erica D’Eramo is joined by Brooke Taylor, a transformational career coach for female leaders, organizational consultant, speaker, and former Marketing Lead at Google. Brooke was named a “Top Career Coach to Watch” by the Australian Business Journal in 2021 and has served as an in-house coach for female executives at Google, Uber, and McKinsey. Through her workshops and coaching programs, she has supported more than 5,000 women globally.

The discussion centers around Brooke’s concept of “The Success Wound,” which she defines as the pain high-achievers experience when they mistake success for self-worth. Together, Erica and Brooke explore how ambition, identity, perfectionism, and external validation become intertwined, particularly for women navigating high-performance environments and systems built around competition, scarcity, and achievement.

It’s a thoughtful episode filled with candor, humility, and practical reflection on what it means to pursue success consciously, rather than automatically.

Growing Up Around Achievement

Brooke begins by sharing her upbringing in Silicon Valley before it became the global tech hub many people recognize today. Surrounded by ambitious families and immersed in a culture that celebrated achievement above all else, she internalized the belief that success and accomplishment determined personal worth.

That mindset followed her through school and into the corporate world:

  • Good grades became validation

  • Career advancement became proof of value

  • Prestigious roles created a sense of legitimacy

Working at Google provided external markers of success that many people aspire toward. Yet beneath that achievement, Brooke describes a persistent sense of emptiness and anxiety:

“I’m only as good as my last piece of feedback.”

That disconnect between external success and internal fulfillment became the foundation of what she now calls the success wound.

Why High-Achieving Women Often Experience This Differently

One of the major themes throughout the episode is the way this dynamic often shows up for women in particular.

Erica notes how frequently she sees women following a clearly defined path of achievement, only to eventually reach a point where they begin questioning whether the version of success they’ve been pursuing actually aligns with what they want.

Brooke expands on this by discussing several overlapping pressures:

  • The expectation to succeed quickly

  • Competition for limited leadership opportunities

  • The pressure to “prove” women belong in positions of power

  • The added complexity of caregiving and family expectations

  • Scarcity dynamics that encourage comparison and overperformance

The episode also explores how these pressures can become internalized over time, shaping the way people evaluate their own worth and measure their progress.

Separating Identity from Achievement

A turning point in Brooke’s own journey came when she began examining the systems and beliefs she had internalized around success.

Rather than continuing to climb ladders by default, she started asking deeper questions:

  • What does success actually mean to me?

  • Where did my beliefs about achievement come from?

  • Am I pursuing goals from alignment or from fear?

  • What parts of my ambition are rooted in external validation?

This process eventually led Brooke out of the corporate environment and into coaching work focused on helping women define success more consciously and sustainably.

The discussion also explores how many achievement-driven behaviors initially develop as protective strategies. Perfectionism, overworking, people-pleasing, and constant striving often begin as adaptive ways to seek safety, belonging, or approval.

The “Protector Self” and the “True Self”

One of the frameworks Brooke shares throughout the episode is the distinction between the “protector self” and the “true self.”

According to Brooke:

  • The protector self develops strategies designed to avoid shame, rejection, or failure

  • The true self reflects a deeper, more grounded sense of identity, intuition, and authenticity

Protector strategies can look like:

  • Perfectionism

  • Hustling and overworking

  • Difficulty saying no

  • Seeking constant validation

  • Hiding or staying small out of fear

  • Cycling between overachievement and burnout

Brooke describes the healing process as learning to recognize these protective patterns while creating space for the true self to step forward more fully.

Redefining Success

As the episode develops, Erica asks what a “healed” success wound actually looks like.

Brooke describes this state as “conscious success,” which she defines as:

“The freedom and fulfillment that comes from following the directions of your true self rather than constantly trying to prove your worth.”

This does not mean abandoning ambition or rejecting achievement altogether. Instead, it involves redefining success in ways that are internally aligned rather than externally driven.

For Brooke, conscious success includes:

  • Spaciousness and flexibility

  • Meaningful impact

  • Alignment with personal values

  • Sustainable ambition

  • Enjoyment and fulfillment

  • A reduced dependence on external validation

The episode also acknowledges that this is not a one-time transformation. Erica reflects on how old achievement patterns can easily resurface, particularly when returning to environments or systems that originally reinforced them.

Purpose, Passion, and Internal Guidance

The discussion eventually shifts toward the concepts of purpose and passion, which Brooke frames less as destinations to “find” and more as ways of being.

Rather than viewing purpose as a specific title or career path, Brooke describes it as:

  • Living in alignment with values

  • Trusting internal guidance

  • Operating from a grounded sense of self

  • Making decisions from wholeness rather than fear

Passion, in turn, emerges when that aligned way of being intersects with genuine interest and engagement.

Both Erica and Brooke note how easy it can be to get distracted by external markers of success or “shiny object syndrome,” particularly in cultures that reward constant striving and comparison.

Implications for Leaders and Organizations

Toward the end of the episode, Erica asks Brooke what leaders and organizations can do to create healthier workplace cultures.

Brooke suggests looking at toxic workplace behaviors through a different lens. Rather than seeing controlling or cutthroat behavior solely as a performance issue, she encourages leaders to recognize that these dynamics are often rooted in insecurity, fear, and unmet needs for safety or power.

The episode emphasizes the importance of:

  • Psychological safety

  • Human-centered leadership

  • Coaching and self-awareness

  • Creating cultures where worth is not solely tied to productivity or status

Resources from Brooke Taylor

Brooke offers a free “Get Unstuck” worksheet through her website to help individuals reflect on their current career path, reconnect with their own definition of fulfillment, and begin exploring what a more aligned next step could look like.

Listeners can learn more and download the worksheet through Brooke Taylor Coaching.

Final Reflection

At its core, this episode explores the difference between achievement and fulfillment.

The success wound often develops quietly, reinforced over years through school, work, family systems, and cultural expectations. For many people, achievement becomes so closely tied to identity that it can be difficult to recognize where striving ends and self-worth begins.

As Erica and Brooke discuss throughout the episode, healing that relationship does not require abandoning ambition. It asks for something more nuanced: the willingness to examine why we are striving, whose definition of success we are pursuing, and whether the life we are building actually feels aligned once we arrive there.